Why Depriving Yourself Will Never Work When It Comes to Weight Loss
I used to be the queen of deprivation. I used to think that was the best way to get what I wanted, not just with my weight, but also when it came to spending money – with everything – but now I realize I was so wrong.
I can remember every time I started a new diet I would pretend I was happy about it when I was really miserable inside. When I’d be out, or at work, I’d look around at what everybody else was eating and despite salivating I’d think okay, once I get this weight off, I’m gonna down a whole box of cookies, but first, I need to lose the weight so for the next two months I’m not going to eat any cakes, candies or cookies or anything else I like to eat, and then I will.
Looking back, I think to myself, “How much sense did that make?” I mean honestly. It’s utterly insane yet I did it all the time. Sometimes as often as every few weeks! I used to come up with these crazy rules too, i.e. I would start a diet at 1pm on a Friday and I had until 1 pm four Fridays from that Friday to lose ten pounds. There was no strategy in place mind you, I just had to achieve the goal by that date.
Then, another time, in an effort to not deprive myself, I went on the all pudding diet, where the only thing I could eat was pudding, which you can imagine after so much pudding, you don’t want any more pudding. That completely backfired.
One reason it did backfire though was because I was in fact depriving myself, just in another way. I wasn’t getting any greens or protein or good fats so my body starting sending me signals to force me to start eating other foods, which, in my mind, translated to failure because I couldn’t stick to just eating pudding.
I also used to suffer from anxiety as a kid and young adult and when my anxiety would peak, I couldn’t eat, which I saw as a good thing because I’d always lose weight. Sometimes my panic attacks lasted weeks or even months, and I’d always drop fat, so that was one strategy I used to lose weight too, but it’s not one I would recommend. In fact, none of these are! They’re silly ideas we come up with when we get desperate.
Chronic dieters are commonly known for depriving themselves, which just sets them up for failure because the state of deprivation causes your body to think you’re in starvation mode, as if you’re on a desert island, so it slows down metabolism, shuts off fat burning, and stores fat. So starving yourself by depriving yourself doesn’t work either.
I was programmed from a very young age, as most of us are, that there are certain food rules that we must follow in order to lose weight and one of them is to deprive ourselves of all the foods we love. We begin to believe that it’s absolutely essential to the process and if we fail at depriving ourselves, then we fail at weight loss and I can tell you that from my own experience that nothing could be further from the truth.
For starters, I don’t know how to deprive myself. I am just not good at it. When I want something, I want it and there is no stopping me, so I get it. I don’t think about the money, I don’t think about how fat it’s going to make me, I don’t think about what anybody thinks. I just get it.
And the same goes for food because if I tell myself no, I’ll just keep thinking about whatever it is I want. My desire for it isn’t going to miraculously just go away. It’s not going to disappear and go b’ bye just because I use my willpower to make it go away.
So I eat it, and I’m not fat. I don’t eat heaping handfuls of whatever it is, but I eat it, but if you want to know a secret, the truth is sometimes I do binge on it and overeat, and I’m still not fat.
Because there are times when I overeat or binge eat, because I have my moments like everyone else, but I’m not fat. It’s not all day everyday like it once was. Not even close. But I do and I just let it go. I figure that I either didn’t eat a balanced meal last time I ate so I got too hungry, or it’s so good that I eat beyond being satiated, or I’m avoiding something – whatever the case may be. And so what? I’m not perfect. None of us are. But I’m in much more control that I would be if I tried to deny myself and not eat whatever it is I’m craving.
When I left my job, I virtually stopped binge eating and overeating altogether. It became practically nonexistent because I stopped hating my life. I started to live with passion, and began loving what I do, and my focus became my work vs food so I now know that when I do binge or overeat, it just means something is off, physically or emotionally, and I fix it and move on.
I look for the reasons behind my actions and determine what made me react that way, without self-judgement, because I love food and I am not about to go through life not eating food that makes me happy. Because it does. It just does. Food is one of the greatest pleasures we have so it doesn’t make sense to.
We have a skewed view on pleasure in our society anyways, in that something that brings us pleasure should make us feel guilty. I’d love to know who came up with that.
One caveat I have though about what I eat is that it is the highest quality food. Organic, hormone free, gluten free, dairy free food. Low sugar and raw when possible. Those are my food rules.
By eating this way, there is never a need for me to feel guilty and I don’t feel deprived.
When you deprive yourself, you just wind up way worse off because it becomes an obsession and when you finally do give in (because you will), your binges will last for weeks, sometimes years, so just let yourself have it now, just upgrade the quality of your food and balance it out. That way you’ll never feel like you’re missing anything and you’ll take your focus off the food on your plate and put it on non-food forms of food such as inspiring work, quality relationships, or moving your body in ways that you love.
When you do that, you’ll be fed in ways that food itself could never feed you.
If your New Year’s Resolutions have already become a thing of the past, then join me for more secrets to natural weight loss on Wednesday, January 25th @8pm EST/5pm PST for my FREE CALL: How to Make 2012 Your Year to Lose BIG and Gain Calm, Confidence and Clarity



Araceli
I have to say that when I left my job and became a full time entrepreneur, I finally learned to stop the binging! I remember one time my boss made my so angry, on my way home I bought Dulce de Leche Haagen Dazs ice cream and an assortment of “toppings” and ate it all in front of the TV. Being in a unhappy place in life definitely makes things a lot more complicated! Thanks for sharing your story.
Angela Minelli
I love it Araceli! For sure, that will bring on a binge. And how miraculous it is when it stops. Great insight!
Jeanny Busacca
Thank you for sharing your story so candidly and honestly. You are helping so many women and men.
Angela Minelli
Thanks Jeanny!
Susan Brady
Hi Angela! I wish more people would read this and take your advise. There are way too many people that try all these crazy diets, and bottom line is it all comes back and sometimes “in abundance” if you know what I mean. Everything in moderation. Food is meant to be enjoyed, no need to feel guilty.
Angela Minelli
I literally LOL’d when I read your post Susan – “in abundance!” Yes, so true, people fall for the gimmicky marketing and they’re just worse off and not only that, feeling dejected and like a failure on top of it. Death to dieting I say! :)
Joyce Sobotta
Angela, What a great article. Thaks for sharing your unpleasant experiences with food because we all know people who have trouble. I was one of thoese people who didn’t want to waste anything so I finished up the leftovers in the serving dishes, only to feel miserable later Shortly after discovering my food sensitivities , I binged on cheese and broke out miserably. Today it is easy for me to by-pass sugar, dairy and gluten foods.
My body just turns away from them because it has learned and doesn’t like to feel miserable. Treating foods with respect for what our bodies tell us makes our life much more meaningful.
Julie Nelson
Angela a great read, and I see how important your story is to share with others. I believe ‘we are what we eat’ Good nutrition is the key to good health. If we eat well, as in a lot of vegetables and fruit, meat if that is a part of your diet, drink a good amount of water and exercise we are on to a great start. What this means is that we can have our treats with out feeling guilty and enjoy them !
Thank you for being true xxx
Julie Nelson
One more thing, I have worked in the Natural therapies industry for over 15 years and remember something I put into practice for a long time and want to start again by the way, Thank you for this has given me a nudge ;) Having fresh vegetable and fruit juices in the morning helps to reduce and even stop cravings. It certainly worked for me!
Dorine Kramer
Angela, I just love reading your stuff–I feel like we’re having a conversation. I absolutely agree with your take on deprivation. It never works and it’s so easy to forget that an unbalanced diet automatically means we are deprived of some nutrients we almost certainly need. And isn’t it bizarre how “we have a skewed view on pleasure in our society anyways, in that something that brings us pleasure should make us feel guilty.” I, too, wonder what depraved (and probably deprived) mind came up with that!
Inspirational Goaling - Lynn Moore
Angela my spunky friend, I’m very happy that I’m not deprived of YOU! What a great article and hits the nail on the head about those ‘limiting beliefs’ we were taught about how depriving ourselves of something, be it food or money or movies or sex, etc. etc. makes us somehow superior. How backward! I remember my Roman Catholic school friends couldn’t eat meat on Fridays….wonder why God changed His mind?
Nourished Health - Katie Bauer
I couldn’t agree with you more Angela! The dieting mindset is so prevalent and depriving ourselves of something never works–it always backfires and results in binge eating and then guilt which causes stress and often more weight gain as a result of the stress. Such a sad cycle. It’s great that you were able to change your habits around food, dieting and deprivation and find happiness with your diet and yourself. You’re a great role model to women. Thanks!